Pope Starts Fight
By Robert Ecksel October 16th, 2005
The view from the Vatican must be different from the view everywhere else. Seat of a world religion, home of spiritual treasures and fine art, when the Vatican speaks, the faithful listen … as do we heathens in the fight game.
A leading Jesuit journal, Civlta Cattolica (“Catholic Civilization”), mouthpiece of the Pontiff’s inner circle, decreed in its recent issue that boxing is bad. In an article titled “The Immorality of Professional Boxing,” the Vatican pulls no punches when it says the sweet science, “From a moral point of view” is “gravely and absolutely negative.”
Boxing certainly is “grave” and “absolute” – no argument there – but “gravely and absolutely negative?” And we thought redemption was your thing.
After comparing boxing to the gladiatorial contests in ancient Rome, about which the church knows a thing or two, the author of the article got down to business: “Professional boxing is manipulated by powerful economic groups, which are often ruthless and cruel, and for whom the boxer is not a man but only a machine to make money.”
Boxing is “manipulated by powerful economic groups,” no doubt about it, but so is everything else, including the church. And if history is any guide, “ruthlessness” and “cruelty” are not the province of boxing promoters alone.
Riccardo De Girolami, secretary-general of the Italian Boxing Federation, read the article and claimed it was full of “clichés” about boxing. “They don’t really know the sport,” he said. “The competitive level is like any other sport.”
The article in Civilta Cattolica even goes so far as to describe boxing as a “legalized form of attempted murder”; it is, in that regard, like war.
From their perspective, these must look like the end times to the pope and his crew. Floods, earthquakes, plague, pestilence, famine … it’s like something plucked from the pages of the bible. But it’s always apocalypse now – pick a century – pick a continent – pick a natural resource – and things don’t look to change any time too soon.
If the church with its zillions and moral high ground wants to fight the good fight and clean up the planet, we’re in your corner, let’s lace up gloves, let’s get it on; but every great champ needs a great opponent … Why go after your own?
Countless boxers over time have been good (and bad) Catholics. Think of all the rough-and-tumble Irish pugs, the legions of never-say-die Italian scrappers, the little kids from way back when with their rebellious athleticism quitting the rosary for the ring: the Sullivans, Corbetts, Fitzsimmons, Tunneys and McLarnins; the Marcianos, Grazianos, Peps, Canzoneris and Basilios; the Carpentiers and Cerdans; the Arguellos and Monzons; the Zales and the Zivics; the whole fantastic dazzling kaleidoscopic array of Catholic warrior-heroes.
War, hunger, poverty, grotesque inequality on a global scale – those are fights the church needs to make to prove its mettle. For the church to pick on a lowly sport is not a sign of strength, it’s a sign of guile. Attacking boxing is not naïve; it’s a ruse.
October 16th, 2005 at 9:19 pm
I say “Right On” Vatican
October 16th, 2005 at 9:22 pm
When I read about the article against boxing, I thought to myself, “We should care about their opinion–why?” There are bigger issues for the Catholic Church to worry about like their internal problems with priests and molestation for example.
October 17th, 2005 at 12:08 pm
I am a Christian, and while that is different from being a Catholic, we both believe violence is not the answer to most situations. That being said, it is AN answer in some. I am a huge fan of boxing, and see absolutely nothing immoral about it. Violence is part of our history and the churches as well, so why deny it? Somebody tell the Pope to stop Bush from dragging us into WW3. That would be a better use of his time
October 18th, 2005 at 1:39 am
I think the comment which says there are cliches can be added to by saying there are rash and foolish generalisations. There are many unsavoury characters, but that can be said in any sport or business. There are also many very good people who have done their best over the years to care and protect their fighters and have been as honest as possible in their dealings. To have attacked them is unfair and smacks of injustice. I am not sure the author of the article has much knowledge of Boxing, professional or otherwise. To compare it to war is also inaccurate as there is no intent to kill.
People are allowed their views, to disagree with this does not make one a heathen, nor does it make all fighters and promoters evil or sinful….it is possible to respect but disagree. In this instance I do.
November 21st, 2007 at 9:32 pm
I have not read the article by the Vatican, but I believe the Church looks at it like this:
Man is made in the image and likeness of God. We should respect our bodies, not harm them. In other pro sports you may have a chance of getting hurt, but it is usually not intentional. Boxing and other fighting “sports” are intentional.