Archive for November, 2005

Grant: MITCHELL’S NO PUSHOVER, BUT NOT FLOYD’S EQUAL

Tuesday, November 15th, 2005

TSS Predictions

Floyd Mayweather is an elite fighter at the peak of his abilities. His hand speed is as good or better than anyone’s in the game. He also punches with authority (despite critics’ claims about his so-called lack of power), can throw every punch in the book with precision, and has a rock solid chin. However, what sets him apart is his thorough knowledge of the game combined with the physical equipment and conditioning to execute the toughest of fight plans. Sharmba Mitchell is an outstanding fighter in his own right. Blessed with tremendous hand speed and an ability to pull punchers out of position, he has found a way to win 56 out of 60 fights and capture a belt along the way. He’s no pushover. What he does not have, however, is solid power. He has never stopped a top fighter. Indeed in winning and defending his WBA junior welterweight belt four times he went the distance each time. A fighter who can not hurt “Pretty Boy” Floyd cannot beat him. It’s just that simple. Don’t look for Mitchell to lay down; that’s not his character. He will give it his all but it won’t be enough. Mayweather by KO in 10.

JE Grant

(JE Grant is a featured writer at The Sweet Science. To access his work, simply click here)

NO ONE IS SAFE FROM “OPERATION CLEANUP III”

Sunday, November 13th, 2005

Sloggin' Thru the Blog

I thoroughly enjoyed writing the “Operation Cleanup” books. In undertaking that project, my goal was to put something together covering the kind of ground that had to date been unexplored in boxing. And to that degree, it was successful; there was never anything like it before and will never be anything like it again, since by definition anything that resembled it would have to be derivative of it.

Though not something for a mass market, the electronic books, which rolled out on a chapter-by-chapter basis in serial form on my Total Action website, were incredibly well-received by ardent fans, as well as “insiders” in the boxing community.

And no one seems to have forgotten them. I can’t begin to tell you how many people approach me, whether it be in person, by phone or email, asking, “When are you going to do another Operation Cleanup?”

Well, friends and fans, that day may be close at hand.

I am expecting that by December or January, there will be the unveiling of OPERATION CLEANUP III: BASTARD PEOPLE - once again, coming down the pike in serial form, story by story, “bullet by bullet.” I honestly couldn’t tell you how long it’s going to be, but I can guarantee I wouldn’t be writing another Operation Cleanup book just for the sake of getting some exercise.

Anyone who knows me understands that I am basically a very nice, friendly, agreeable person. Of course, there’s another side as well. When it came to the dishonest, disreputable, scurrilous, incompetent characters in boxing, the side of me that is a little mean, nasty and ruthless surfaced in Operation Cleanup and Operation Cleanup 2, as well as the latest book, Body Shots . We put a lot of pressure on a lot of people – successful in putting some of them in their place and blasting others OUT of their place.

But even those who know me best may not be aware of precisely how intense, surgical, mean, nasty, ruthless, fierce, brutal, savage, ferocious, fervent, dogged, unflinching and unyielding I can possibly be.

With OPERATION CLEANUP III: BASTARD PEOPLE, everyone’s about to find out – some at a distance, others at dangerously close range.

Sure, I’ll revisit a few of our old “pals” from the previous Operation Cleanup books, but in OPERATION CLEANUP III: BASTARD PEOPLE I’ll be introducing a whole new cast of characters – all nefarious, dastardly or megalomaniacal in their own way, previously untouched and untraversed. How appetizing is THAT?

If you’re the type of person who goes in for this kind of thing (and you know who you are), OPERATION CLEANUP III: BASTARD PEOPLE will probably be the most entertaining boxing book you’ll ever read.

So get set to go on another thrill ride.

And pray real hard that you won’t be staring down the business end of my pen.

(If you would like to be apprised of updates on OPERATION CLEANUP III: BASTARD PEOPLE, as well as previews before the stories are posted, please write to me at charlesjay99@gmail.com and I’ll put you on the mailing list. Also, continue to check with my column here on the blog for updates)

KAPLAN: THE SEARCH FOR JIM ROBINSON

Sunday, November 13th, 2005

Boxing Channel
Hank Kaplan

In February of 1961, a fighter named Jim Robinson, allegedly out of Kansas City, climbed into a Miami Beach ring with 19-year-old Cassius Clay as a last-minute substitute and was summarily dismissed inside of one round. By virtue of that bout, Robinson became a footnote in history, but in a bizarre way, he has become much more significant. As the Ali legend became firmly established and the “industry” surrounding him grew and grew, collectors and those in the literary world sought out each of The Greatest’s opponents for commercial purposes. The only one they could not find was Jim Robinson. To this day, his fate is not known, despite the efforts of autograph dealers, historians, even private investigators, to the point where his disappearance has become a cult legend of sorts, in and of itself.

Hank Kaplan, the world’s foremost boxing historian and archivist, is one of those people who has looked for any trace of Robinson, to no avail. He discusses the story with Charles Jay of Boxing Channel Radio.

To listen to the podcast, please click the icon below. And please, allow a moment or two for it to download.

Podcast

MOHEGAN SUN HOSTS ABC OFFICIALS’ SEMINAR DEC. 10-11

Saturday, November 12th, 2005

The Mohegan Tribal Department of Athletic Regulation will play host to the annual officials’ seminar of the Association of Boxing Commissions (ABC), to be held Saturday, December 10 and Sunday, December 11 at the Mohegan Sun Casino in Uncasville, CT. The Saturday session will be conducted for judges by Duane Ford, the well-respected judge affiliated with the Nevada State Athletic Commission, and on Sunday, Armando Garcia, the executive director of the California State Athletic Commission, will instruct the referees. Each of the sessions will last from 8 AM to 3 PM.

A special room rate for officials is available at the Best Western Cristata Inn, 2255 Norwich New London Turnpike in Uncasville. Call 860-848-0660 for reservations.

Mohegan Sun also hosts the Ronald “Winky” Wright-Sam Soliman fight at the casino/resort that weekend (December 10).

More information can be obtained from Mike Mazzulli, executive director of the Mohegan Tribal Department of Athletic Regulation, who is also Vice-President of the ABC, at 860-862-7583.

Boxing Channel Radio

Charles Jay of Boxing Channel had the pleasure of speaking at the Mohegan Sun Casino on June 18, when the tribal commission held a two-day seminar for its own officials. If you’d like to listen to that speech, please click the icon below. It is rather lengthy, so please allow some extra time for it to download to your computer.

Podcasts

BOXER DIES WITH IMPUNITY

Wednesday, November 9th, 2005

When Beethavean Scottland, a 26-year-old light-heavyweight from North Brentwood, Maryland, was beaten into a coma by George Khalid Jones on June 26, 2001 aboard the USS Intrepid, an aircraft carrier/war museum dry-docked on the Hudson River, it send shock waves through the New York boxing community. Fingers pointed, tongues wagged, wrists got slapped, the state got a new commissioner, who rearranged the furniture, and it was back to business as usual.

At the time it looked like those who might have been responsible for the boxer’s death got off scot-free.

And now it’s official.

Last week Manhattan Supreme Court, Justice Sherry Klein Heitler dismissed a negligence lawsuit filed by Beethavean Scottland’s widow Denise against the two ringside physicians presiding that night, Drs. Gerard Varlotta and Rufus Sadler. The suit alleges, not unreasonably, that her husband was “unreasonably and violently pummeled” during the fight. But after lawyers for the doctors argued that the suit was alleging medical malpractice, and not medical negligence, and that the statute of limitations for such a claim had expired, the judge agreed and threw the case out of court.

“The court finds,â€? Judge Heitler wrote in Scottland v. Duva Boxing, 109169/04, “the physician defendants were retained as ringside physicians in their capacity as physicians, and they were charged with the duty to exercise reasonable medical care to provide an ongoing medical diagnosis of the boxing participants’ physical condition throughout the match. This holding is consistent with the boxer’s reasonable expectation that a ringside physician will call the match if necessary to protect his or her well-being, as well as attend to any injuries the boxer sustains during the match.”

Scottland’s wife initiated the present action on June 21, 2004, a week short of the third anniversary of the bout. The timing of the filing became crucial, as it fell within the three-year statute of limitation for personal injury claims, but outside the two-and-a-half-year statute for medical malpractice claims.

Separate actions against New York State, the New York State Athletic Commission, and Duva Boxing are ongoing in the Court of Claims, according to an attorney for the plaintiff.

“In sum,â€? concluded Judge Heitler, “the court’s review of the applicable regulations leads it to conclude that the Legislature’s primary purpose in requiring the presence of ringside physicians, in addition to the referee and other personnel, is to ensure the safety of the match participants. In this regard, this case falls outside the rubric of those cited by plaintiff for the proposition that no physician-patient relationship existed between Scottland and defendants. In essence, then, plaintiff’s claims against [the defendants] sound in medical malpractice and have expired under the applicable Statute of Limitations.”

There ought to be a law against paying lawyers in lieu of paying a dead boxer’s widow. Too bad it makes no dollars and sense.

RUIZ FIRES AWAY AT VITALI — DO YOU AGREE WITH HIS STATEMENT?

Tuesday, November 8th, 2005

Boxing News

By way of a press release, John Ruiz (or whoever wrote this for him) piled on Vitali Klitschko, who pulled out of his WBC heavyweight title fight with Hasim Rahman with a knee injury.

“I’m not surprised and I don’t think too many people in boxing are really surprised. First it was his hamstring injury from jogging, then it spread to his back, and now it’s his knee. It’s always something with this guy. They should really check his heart. HBO, Ring and anybody else that supports this guy as the so-called real heavyweight champion of the world should be ashamed of themselves. They have their own agendas. Klitschko doesn’t want to fight anybody he can’t handpick. Who has he ever beaten? World champions have to defend their title against the best opponents in the world. The WBC should strip him of the belt and award it to Rahman. Klitschko should pay Rahman for all of the time he’s wasted training. They had to force him to fight Rahman and he still pulled out. What does Klitschko mean in Russian, chicken? He quit on the stool with a shoulder injury against (Chris) Byrd in the 10th round of a 12-round fight that he was leading big. A doctor gave him approval to fight Rahman, but he chose not to fight. He’s tall, big and may look like a heavyweight champion. But he doesn’t have the heart and soul of a world champ. It’s not what’s on the outside, it’s what’s inside that counts.

Also…………

“I’ve never ducked anybody. Nobody ever had to force me to fight a mandatory. I’m going halfway around the world to fight a giant – one-foot taller and 100-pounds heavier than me – in his backyard because I’m a true world champion. Valuev is my mandatory and after I take care of that fight, I’m pushing hard once again for a tournament so the public will have one heavyweight champion. Klitschko’s the reason we haven’t had a tournament because he wants to pick and choose his opponents like (Danny) Williams, (Oleg) Maskaev or (Calvin) Brock), instead of putting his belt on the line against one of the other champions. If the WBC does the right thing and makes Rahman the new champion like he deserves, boxing will be able to have a tournament next year and the public will know who the real man is in the heavyweight division, John Ruiz. Compare my record to any of the other heavyweight champions.”

What do you think of that statement?

– Has Klitschko beaten only “handpicked” opponents?
– Should the WBC strip Klitschko of the belt and give it to Rahman?
– Does Ruiz’s record actually stack up favorably to the other heavyweight champions, as he contends?

Let us know.

KING PUTS OUT SPIN ON KLITSCHKO SITUATION

Tuesday, November 8th, 2005

Boxing News

Here is the material being put out by Don King Productions in reaction to Vitali Klitschko pulling out of Saturday’s previously scheduled fight with Hasim Rahman due to inujury:

(FROM PRESS RELEASE)

DEERFIELD BEACH, Fla.—To make an informed conclusion on whether Vitali Klitschko should be stripped of the World Boxing Council heavyweight championship for failing, on four separate occasions this year, to face his mandatory challenger Hasim “The Rock� Rahman, the following chronology of events should be considered:

• Vitali Klitschko has never made a mandatory defense of a world title (WBC or WBO).

• Vitali Klitschko defeats Corrie Sanders by technical knockout in round eight on April 24, 2004, at Staples Center in Los Angeles to win the vacant WBC heavyweight title (vacated by Lennox Lewis).

• Pursuant to “WBC Rule 1.25 Vacant Title,� Klitschko was able to petition the WBC “to approve one voluntary defense, with the condition that the winner must meet his official challenger next.� The WBC granted the exception paving the way for Klitschko to meet Danny Williams on Dec. 11, 2004.

• Hasim Rahman defeats Kali “Checkmate� Meehan in New York in a WBC heavyweight championship elimination bout on Nov. 13, 2004, to become the WBC mandatory challenger.

• Vitali Klitschko makes an optional defense against Danny Williams in Los Angeles on Dec. 11, 2004, winning by technical knockout in round eight.

• Tom Loeffler, Klitschko’s promoter at K2 Promotions, states on Dec. 24, 2004, that Vitali’s hands “were badly swollen but not broken� after his fight with Williams and that the timetable for future bouts “depends on Vitali’s hands.�

• Klitschko agrees in February 2005 to make a mandatory defense against Rahman on April 30, 2005, at New York’s Madison Square Garden.

• The April 30, 2005, meeting is rescheduled to June 18, 2005, after Vitali suffers what is called a “thigh injury� while jogging.

• Klitschko re-schedules this mandatory defense to July 23, 2005, claiming his thigh did not respond to treatment.

• The July 23, 2005, re-scheduling is postponed yet again after Klitschko claims his thigh injury has spread to his back.

• Klitschko undergoes what his handlers refer to as “minor back surgery,� on April 19, 2005.

• “WBC Rule 1.27 Inactivity of a Champion� states: “When a world champion is:

a) inactive for more than six (6) months but less than one (1) year, for certified medical reasons, or

b) for whatever legal impediment or other reason beyond his control is unable to defend his championship within the time periods prescribed by the Rules and Regulations, the WBC may determine an interim champion pursuant to Rule 1.25 hereof.�

• Don King Productions successfully petitions the WBC in May 2005 to sanction for its interim heavyweight championship on Aug. 13, 2005, the match between WBC No. 1-ranked mandatory challenger Hasim Rahman and WBC No. 2-ranked, and No. 2 mandatory challenger Monte “Two Gunz� Barrett pursuant to WBC Rule 1.27.

• Don King implores Klitschko to face Rahman on Aug. 13, avoiding the necessity of the interim championship bout. Klitschko claims he cannot be ready to fight by Aug. 13. After Rahman and Barrett sign to fight each other, it is leaked to the media that Klitschko suddenly recovers to the extent that he is fit to fight on HBO Sept. 24. Klitschko’s hand-picked
opponent, Oleg Maskaev, is subsequently rejected by HBO as a suitable opponent according to media reports.

• Klitschko subsequently petitions the WBC to allow him a second voluntary defense against Calvin Brock on Sept. 24, 2005. The WBC rejects Klitschko’s bid on July 15, 2005, and orders Vitali to face the winner of Rahman vs. Barrett.

• The WBC announces on Aug. 17, 2005, that Klitschko will make his thrice-delayed mandatory defense against Rahman on Nov. 12, 2005, at the Thomas and Mack Center in Las Vegas.

• Klitschko is reportedly “knocked down� and “banged up� by sparring partners during the first week in November to the extent he claims a knee injury. Two doctors fit Vitali with two different knee braces, but it was never reported that either physician determined that Klitschko’s apparent knee injury would prevent him from fighting on Nov. 12.

• Vitali Klitschko himself makes the decision to pull out of the Rahman fight on Nov. 5, 2005.

• “WBC Rule 1.28 Penalty on Inactivity by Champion (or Interim Champion)� states: “A champion (or an interim champion) not defending his title within one (1) year will lose his title.� Therefore, if Klitschko is not able to face Rahman by Dec. 11, 2005, (one year since Klitschko last defended his title against Danny Williams), the WBC must, by its own Rules and
Regulations strip him of his title. Furthermore:

• “WBC Rule 1.29 Penalty on Refusal to Fight� states: “If any of both, the WBC Champion [Klitschko] and the interim champion [Rahman] , is not willing to participate in a contest to have one sole undisputed champion in the division, he [Klitschko] will lose his portion of the title, with the willing champion [Rahman] becoming automatically, the undisputed WBC
Champion of the division.� Therefore, the WBC must declare Rahman its heavyweight champion by Dec. 10, 2005, pursuant to rules 1.28 and 1.29, if it follows its own Rules and Regulations. Any deviation from the aforementioned Rules and Regulations would certainly leave the WBC open to needless and unnecessary lawsuits for obvious violations of its own Rules and Regulations.

• “WBC Rule 1.21 Championship Defense Obligations� states: “b) Mandatory Defense Obligations. All WBC recognized champions are obligated to make at least one yearly mandatory defense against the designated official challenger [Rahman].� It further states: “Mandatory Defenses. A WBC champion is obligated to make at least one yearly mandatory defense against the designated official challenger [Rahman].�

What do YOU think? Let us know.

IS ALI DEAD AND DYING?

Sunday, November 6th, 2005

Former heavyweight champion Muhammad Ali, whose health has been dicey, putting it mildly, forever, has apparently taken a turn for the worse. According to a report published in the London Evening Standard earlier this week, The Greatest is losing his two-decade long battle with Parkinson’s disease and he may be dying.

Quoting an unnamed family friend, “[Ali’s] condition has worsened. At this point, he may only have months to live.”

Those who get their “news� from the news are at a big disadvantage when it comes to discerning fact from fiction, truth from lies, patriotism from agitprop, fear mongering from human decency … especially when it comes to Ali – one of the most beloved – and one of the most exploited – men on the face of the planet.

As to the current state of his health, even those in Ali’s inner circle seem unable to get their stories straight. His marketing agent, Harlan Werner, denied the news report. He told BBC Sport that “Muhammad is fine and he has numerous appearances lined up. He had surgery on his back and was in therapy for that, but that had nothing to do with Parkinson’s. He is fine. It is disrespectful to Muhammad to suggest that he would not tell the truth about his health.”

That’s a marketing agent for you.

Ali’s longtime friend, photographer and manager, Howard Bingham, who is as close to Ali as anyone on the planet, said, “[His daughter] Laila feels she is losing him.”

Laila Ali, in a story printed in the Los Angeles Times, more or less agreed: “I feel like the disease is progressing. Different things start happening as you get older. I have noticed a change in him, something that goes along with Parkinson’s.â€?

Not to mention the debilitating effects of boxing.

“It’s painful for me,â€? she continued, “because I would love to sit down and talk to my dad about the way he used to be when he was my age, when he was in his prime, because we are so much alike. I can’t really do that. I can’t share a lot of things with him.”

She also revealed, according to the British-based Mirror, that the 63-year-old former world heavyweight champ has stopped talking to others and has shut himself away from the world.

With all the leeches out there, who can blame him?

Human nature being what it is (and, alas, what it is not), we seem hardwired to make heroes out of mortals, gods out of men, turning flesh and blood into plaster of Paris. But rather than deify, idolize, fawn and drool over a man whose faults, like his virtues, are huge, we should be graceful enough, grateful enough, to leave Ali alone.

JE Grant: LOOK FOR A ONE-SIDED AFFAIR

Thursday, November 3rd, 2005

TheSweetScience.com Predictions
One of the usual laments among boxing writers and fans is that we have no superstar to save the sport. As usual, the answer is under our collective noses in the form of Jeff Lacy. His unique, power-based constant attack in the ring coupled with his engaging personality outside of it is a combination that could vault him to fame beyond the confines of the boxing world. However, while he awaits the fights that will serve as the platform for his jump to glory, he will have to meet and beat solid contenders such as Scott Pemberton and do so convincingly. Pemberton is no stranger to meeting so-called name fighters, though with mixed results. Two victories over perennial title-challenger Omar Sheika, and a loss to former titlist Charles Brewer is the extent of his resume with the division’s established contenders. He’s proven that he’s resilient, willing and has some kick. He’s also not especially difficult to hit – an ominous attribute when facing the swarming Lacy. Pemberton is well-respected and deservedly so – but he’s a significant notch below the ever-improving “Left Hook.” Combine that with the fact that he’s been off for a year and he’s 38 years old, we should look for this to be a one-sided affair. Lacy by KO in 5.

JE Grant

Kimball: LACY SHOULD PREVAIL IN MIDDLE ROUNDS

Thursday, November 3rd, 2005

TSS Predictions
Scott Pemberton is 38 years of age and hasn’t fought in over a year, primarily because after earning mandatory position in the WBC rankings he had to sit idle while Los Bandidos sorted out their own pecking order. He beat Omar Sheika twice and then had to sit back and watch Sheika fight for a title, and is only in this one because an injury to Danny Green scuttled a WBC eliminator in Australia just about the same time Joe Calzaghe ducked out of a proposed fight against Lacy. It’s actually a pity, because now he’s getting his first – and, probably, only – title shot against the super-middleweight champion he is least likely to beat. The two are familiar with one another – Pemberton sparred extensively with Lacy in California a few years back. Look for Pemberton to do some early damage, much as he did in his fight with Charles Brewer, but Lacy should prevail sometime in the middle rounds.

George Kimball

(George Kimball is a feature writer for The Sweet Science, as well as a writer for the Boston Herald. To access his work, simply Click Here)